Football: Bin Hammam blogger ordered to reveal sources
Above: Mohamed bin Hammam in a 2011 file photo
SINGAPORE - Singapore's High Court ordered a blogger to reveal his sources Friday after he reported that a leaked internal audit detailed large payments to suspended Asian soccer chief Mohamed bin Hammam.
Lawyers for James M. Dorsey, a Singapore-based academic and
journalist, and
the complainant, sports marketing company World Sport Group,
both said the
move was approved after a closed-door session lasting nearly
four hours.
"The application was allowed pending appeal," Dorsey's
lawyer N. Sreenivasan
told AFP.
Dorsey had reported details on his blog, "The Turbulent
World of Middle East Soccer",
of a leaked PricewaterhouseCoopers internal audit of the Asian
Football Confederation
(AFC), which he said listed payments to its president, bin
Hammam.
The multi-million dollar payments were made before the Asian
football body extended
its exclusive marketing and media rights contract with
Singapore-based World Sport
Group, Dorsey said, in a deal reportedly worth $1 billion
(S$1.22 billion).
WSG applied to the High Court to force Dorsey to reveal his source
for the information,
and any related documents, with the intention of launching
possible defamation or
breach of confidence proceedings.
"We want information so we can determine what charges to
make and against whom,"
said Deborah Barker, senior counsel representing WSG.
Dorsey told AFP he was "disappointed" by the ruling,
and confirmed that he planned to
appeal.
"I'm disappointed at the court's ruling and will appeal
it," said the German national, who
is a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International
Studies at Singapore's
Nanyang Technological University.
The case has attracted press freedom concerns from Gianni Merlo,
president of the
Swiss-based international sports media association (AIPS), and
comes at a time of
renewed intrigue related to the bin Hammam situation.
This month, Kong Lee Toong, husband of former AFC finance
director Amelia Gan,
pleaded not guilty in a Malaysian court to charges of stealing a
financial document of
bin Hammam's from the body's Kuala Lumpur headquarters.
Qatar's Hammam, 63, has been suspended from football activities
for more than a year,
after FIFA's ethics committee found him guilty of bribery during
his election campaign to
replace the world body's president, Sepp Blatter.
The bribery case was seen as shedding a light on murky practices
inside FIFA, and
prompted new questions about Qatar's successful bid to host the
2022 World Cup, in
which bin Hammam played a role. The bid, alongside others, is
now under investigation.
However in July, bin Hammam's lifetime ban from football was
overturned by the Court of
Arbitration for Sport on grounds of insufficient
evidence.
The Qatari multi-millionaire, 63, remains provisionally
suspended by both FIFA and the
AFC pending investigations into the Asian body's financial dealings.
WSG, which bills itself as "Asia's leading sports
marketing, media and event management
company", is majority-owned by
French company Lagardere.
It also has global media rights for cricket's Indian Premier
League and is the media and
marketing partner of the OneAsia golf circuit.
Your attorney has some good arguments, James. If they had been more transparent and honest, you wouldn't have needed to use those sources in the first place. To punish the messenger is throwing the game to the cheaters. And it has been proven that you uncovered corruption, so who cares about the sources? The story stands on its own. Imagine what the world would be like today if journalists had disclosed all of their confidential sources over time. They are harboring a lie and trying to turn it on you.
ReplyDelete