Repression of students' dissent is uniting ultras groups and student activists
from across the spectrum.
Al JazeeraLast updated: 04 Dec 2014 12:04
The scale of the recent repression of students and ultras in Egypt is perhaps unprecedented [Getty Images]
|Protests continued on university campuses across Egypt following the court verdict |
that cleared ousted President Hosni Mubarak of charges of killing protesters during
the January 25 uprising.
The protesters comprise a broad mix of Islamists, liberals, leftists, independents and
other non-affiliated students. The scale of protests prompted state-owned news website
Al-Ahram to describe it as Egypt witnessing "a university uprising".
But it was one group of activists that has given a sharper edge to many of the ongoing
protests on university campuses across Egypt since the new academic year began on
October 11: Ultras Nahdawy.
Ultras are generally known as hard-core football fans, but "Nahdawy" activists are not
linked to any team. Most of their original members came from ultras groups supporting
Cairo sporting clubs, al-Ahly Club and Zamalek Club.
According to its spokesperson, they formed a new ultras movement during the 2012
presidential campaign to support the Muslim Brotherhood candidate Mohamed Morsi,
who later won the election. "We were the first political ultras in Egypt," the Nahdawy's
But it was the escalating repression against students that brought the ultras and
students, from across the spectrum, together.
Students have rebelled against a raft of government measures, which include
pre-emptive arrests of students, and the banning of political activities and "insulting" the
president on campus.
Universities have been given a military makeover, with the installation of steel walls,
barbed wire, metal detectors and CCTV, backed by a heavy-handed security presence
in and around campuses.
The new measures were designed to prevent a repeat of the anti-government protests
that occurred during the last academic year, in which at least 16 students were killed
and hundreds arrested.
OPINION: The undone revolution in Egypt
Ultras in Egypt are renowned both for their fanatical support of their clubs and for their
willingness to confront the guns and batons of the security forces.
"We took the culture of the ultras in the stadiums and tried to copy and paste it into the
street," said Zizou, a supporter of al-Ahly who declined to give his real name for security
The majority of Nahdawy members are in high school, but many of the more senior
members are university students.
Ultras Nahdawy members have been a small, but prominent, part of many protests.
Their chants, songs, flares and fireworks have been particularly notable during demonstrations, particularly at al-Azhar and Ain Shams universities. They are also
active in regular Friday protests in their own neighbourhoods.
"Nahda", meaning "renaissance", is the term used to refer to the Muslim Brotherhood's
economic and political project.
The creation of Ultras Nahdawy was controversial among football fans and many chose
to keep their membership hidden after some were booted out of their original ultras
groups when their Nahdawy alliances were discovered.
They claim to put aside their footballing rivalries within their group to focus on the
They were involved in the protests that followed the military's ousting of Morsi in July
Following the violent dispersal of the pro-Morsi sit-in at Rabaa al-Adaweya on August
14, 2013, they were forced underground and began operating secretly to evade the
authorities and occasionally pop-up at demonstrations.
effectively outlaws demonstrations that are not sanctioned
by the authorities.
From an estimated membership of between 1,500 and 2,000,
they claim that around 350 have been arrested and 14 killed
since the military ousted Morsi.Ultras Nahdawy activists claim that they no longer have any
official link with the now-banned Muslim Brotherhood,
although their core demographic still appears to be Islamist.
They say that their membership has widened.
"During the January 25 revolution we had our demands and
they are still the same: bread, freedom, justice," Zizou said.
"But now we are also calling for an end to military rule, freedom for the prisoners of
conscience, and democratisation - because SCAF [the military leadership] violated
democratic principles when they kicked out Morsi."
Morsi, currently imprisoned and facing multiple charges, is reviled by many Egyptians
for his perceived authoritarianism and economic mismanagement while in power.
The Nahdawy are part of a diverse mix of student protesters, many of whom are
secular and oppose the Nahdawy's call for Morsi to return. Yet, repression is forging
a degree of solidarity as students and ultras across the political spectrum call for
academic and political freedom.
Reem Khorshid, a student at Cairo University, in a recent article for the independent
media online platform, Mada Masr, wrote that she knows students who are politically
indifferent but who would side with Muslim Brotherhood-supporting colleagues a
gainst the security forces.
"The state's vendetta against the student body doesn't only include supporters of
ousted President Mohamed Morsi," wrote Khorshid. "All students feel chafed at the
new draconian procedures on campus."
RELATED: Egypt: 'The counterrevolution is at its peak'
In his address at Cairo University in late September, President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi
declared: "I love Egypt's youth and consider them my children," before warning
students against engaging in "malicious" activities and urging them to view the
university as solely for education.
Yet, at least one student has died in ongoing confrontations and at least 230 have
been arrested so far in this academic year as students vent their anger at the security
The authorities' repression of student dissent is part of a wider crackdown on secular
activists, the media, NGOs, and other ultras groups.
A Cairo court is currently considering a lawsuit to ban Zamalek Sporting Club's Ultras
White Knights (UWK) group following a series of clashes in the past few months.
As one of the few groups to regularly confront the security forces in the streets during
Mubarak's era, ultras were active beyond the stadiums long before the formation of
Ultras Nahdawy. When the January 25 uprising broke out in 2011, ultras were at the
forefront of protests that toppled the dictator.
"Spectators have been banned from attending football matches for much of the last
three and a half years and certainly since the Port Said incident in February 2012,
which tells you to what degree the regime views the ultras as a problem or a threat,"
says James M Dorsey, author of a forthcoming book on football in the Middle East.
bymilitant football fans have turned university
campuses into the new stadia", battling with the
authorities over public space.
Some analysts believe the restriction on students, ultras and other groups, may
encourage some to become more politically active, and may push others into
"The crackdown will help to nurture violence among young people in general and
especially among the ultras," says Yasser Thabet, author of several books on
Egyptian ultras and football.
He believes that some may be tempted to join more radical groups. "Due to the
violent confrontations, especially in the universities or at protests, some may
move from direct to indirect confrontation which might include even more violence."
Ultras Nahdawy claim to follow non-violent principles of protest, although Gandhi
might not approve. According to Zizou: "If the police attack us, we defend
ourselves with fireworks."
But they also concede that some members are losing patience with "peaceful"
protest, especially due to the level of violence they are facing from the authorities.
" Against the political ultras [such as Nahdawy], the police use live ammunition and
birdshot," claimed Zizou. "With the sporting ultras, they just arrest them to scare
them or teach them a lesson, to make them bite the bullet. For us it is tougher."
The targeting of students and ultras is nothing new in Egypt, analysts argue, but
the scale of the recent repression is perhaps unprecedented. "We should
assume that if attacks from the police continue, the youth will eventually explode,"
said one ultras activist.
The Globalist's Top Ten Books in 2016: The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer
“The Turbulent World of Middle East Soccer has helped me immensely with great information and perspective.”
Bob Bradley, former US and Egyptian national coach
"James Dorsey’s The Turbulent World of Middle Eastern Soccer (has) become a reference point for those seeking the latest information as well as looking at the broader picture."
Alon Raab in The International Journal of the History of Sport
“Dorsey’s blog is a goldmine of information.”Play the Game"Your expertise is clearly superior when it comes to Middle Eastern soccer."
Andrew Das, The New York Times soccer blog Goal."No one is better at this kind of work than James Dorsey"David Zirin, Sports Illustrated
"Essential Reading"Change FIFA"A fantastic new blog'Richard Whitall of A More Splendid Life"James combines his intimate knowledge of the region with a great passion for soccer"Christopher Ahl, Play the Game"An excellent Middle East Football blog"James Corbett, Inside World Football